American Family Renaissance

How to Pray When You Don’t Know What to Say: Honest Prayer for Men

by Mike Van Pelt | Nov 21, 2026 | Leadership, Faith, Fatherhood, Mindset

My Prayers Sounded Like a Weather Report

If you’ve ever wondered how to pray when you don’t know what to say, you’re in good company. For a long time, my prayers sounded like a weather report.

“Lord, thanks for the day. Be with my family. Help me at work. Amen.”

Same words, same order, every time. I could have recorded it and hit play. It was polite. It was safe. And it never touched anything real going on inside me.

Meanwhile, I was carrying things I never said out loud to anybody, God included. Pressure at work. Worry about my kids. Questions I was embarrassed to ask. I’d sit down to pray, feel the weight of all of it, and freeze. So I’d fall back on the weather report and move on with my day.

Maybe that’s you. Maybe you pray at meals and in church, but when it’s just you and God, you don’t know where to start. Let’s fix that.

Why So Many Men Freeze Up in Prayer

Most men I talk with don’t skip prayer because they don’t believe. They skip it because it feels awkward, and nobody ever showed them how. Here’s what usually gets in the way:

  • We think there’s a right way to sound. We heard the deacon pray with big words and long sentences, and we figured we’d never measure up.
  • We don’t like saying what we feel. Plenty of men have spent a lifetime keeping it all inside. Prayer asks us to open the door we’ve kept locked.
  • We treat God like a boss. We report in, ask for what we need, and get out. That’s a meeting, not a relationship.
  • We feel like we don’t deserve to be heard. After the week we’ve had, it seems strange to show up and talk to God like nothing happened.

If any of those land, you’re not a bad Christian. You’re a man who was never taught. And the good news is that God already knows all of it, and He still wants to hear from you.

Checking In With Scripture: What the Bible Says About Prayer When You Don’t Have the Words

When I went to the Bible with this, I found three truths that took the pressure off.

1. God helps you pray when you can’t

“Likewise the Spirit helps us in our weakness. For we do not know what to pray for as we ought, but the Spirit himself intercedes for us with groanings too deep for words” (Romans 8:26).

Read that slowly. Paul says flat out that we do not know what to pray for. That’s not a failure. That’s normal. And when you run out of words, the Holy Spirit picks up where you left off. A groan, a sigh, a “Lord, I don’t even know” is a real prayer.

2. God isn’t impressed by a lot of words

Jesus said, “When you pray, go into your room and shut the door and pray to your Father who is in secret.” Then He said not to “heap up empty phrases” like people who “think that they will be heard for their many words” (Matthew 6:6-8).

That should come as a relief to every man who thinks he’s bad at praying. Jesus wasn’t looking for polished speeches. He was looking for honest sons who’d close the door and talk to their Father.

3. Your Father already knows, and He still wants to hear it

In the same passage Jesus says, “Your Father knows what you need before you ask him” (Matthew 6:8).

So why pray at all? Because prayer isn’t about informing God. It’s about being with Him. A good dad already knows when his son is struggling, and he still wants his son to come to him and say it. That’s what prayer is.

And look at how Jesus taught us to start: “Our Father” (Matthew 6:9). Not “Dear Sir.” Not “To whom it may concern.” Father. You’re not a stranger filling out a request form. You’re a son.

Talking It Over With the Father: A Simple Way to Pray

When I don’t know what to say, I use five plain steps. They’re not a formula to perform. They’re handholds for a man who’s learning to talk to his Dad.

  1. Be honest. Start with where you actually are. “Father, I’m tired.” “Lord, I’m angry about this.” “God, I don’t feel anything right now.” He can handle the truth.
  2. Read a Psalm. When your words run dry, borrow David’s. Open to Psalm 23, Psalm 46, or Psalm 139, and pray the lines back to God as your own.
  3. Name what you need, for you and for the people you love. Be specific. “Give my son wisdom with this decision.” “Help me be patient with my wife tonight.”
  4. Sit quietly for a minute or two. Don’t fill the silence. Pay attention to what comes to mind, and test it against Scripture.
  5. Thank Him. End by naming two or three things He’s done. Gratitude turns your eyes off the problem and back onto the Father.

Here’s what that can sound like on a hard day:

Father, I’ll be honest. I don’t know what to say, and I’m carrying more than I want to admit. You know all of it already. You said You are my shepherd, and I need that today. Give me wisdom for the decision in front of me, and help me lead my family well tonight. I’m going to be quiet for a minute and listen. Thank You for this morning, for my family, and for never giving up on me. In Jesus’ name, amen.

That’s it. No big words. Just a son talking to his Father.

Pull Up a Second Chair

One of the best pictures of this I’ve ever found comes from my friend Bob Beaudine. Bob is the president and CEO of Eastman & Beaudine, one of the top executive search firms in sports and entertainment, and the author of 2 Chairs: The Secret That Changes Everything. He was also one of our speakers at the American Family Renaissance Power of Asking for Help Men’s Summit.

Bob’s idea is simple. Set out two chairs. Sit in one, and leave the other one empty for God. Picture Him sitting right across from you, because He is with you. Then you don’t recite a speech. You have a conversation.

And Bob gives you three questions to bring into that conversation:

  1. Does God know your situation?
  2. Is it too hard for God to handle?
  3. Does He have a good plan for you?

You already know the answers. Yes, He knows. No, it’s not too hard for Him. Yes, His plan is good. But something happens when a man sits across from his Father and answers those questions out loud about the thing that’s keeping him up at night. The weight shifts. You stop carrying it like it’s all on you.

That’s why those three questions fit right alongside the five steps above. When you don’t know what to say, start there. Pull up the second chair, and ask them about whatever you’re facing today.

Walking It Out: Three Steps for This Week

  1. Pick a time and a place. Jesus said to go into your room and shut the door. For you, that might be the truck before work, the back porch, or the kitchen table before anyone else is up. Same spot, same time, five minutes, for seven days.
  2. Pray one Psalm out loud each day. Out loud matters. It keeps your mind from wandering, and it gets you used to hearing your own voice talk to God. Start with Psalm 23 on day one.
  3. Write down one honest sentence. Before you pray, jot one line in a notebook or on your phone: what you’re really carrying today. Pray that line first. At the end of the week, read the seven lines back and look at how God met you.

If you want more on what God is calling you to as a man, read What Does the Bible Say About Being a Man? If prayer feels hard because you’re running on empty, read Strong, Saved, and Still Exhausted.

Where I Stand

A Christian man who never talks to his Father will drift. Every time. You can’t lead your family, fight temptation, or carry hard seasons on your own strength, and prayer is how you get His. It isn’t an extra for the super-spiritual guys. It’s oxygen.

At the same time, your Father isn’t grading your vocabulary. He isn’t keeping score of the days you missed. He’s waiting at the door for His son to come in and sit down. Show up honest, and He’ll meet you there.

Your Challenge

Tomorrow morning, before you look at your phone, sit down for five minutes and pray one honest sentence you’ve never said to God out loud. Then read Psalm 23 and pray it back to Him.

Then tell me in the comments: what’s the one thing that makes prayer hardest for you?

 

Ready to stop figuring this out alone? I walk with men every week who are learning to know God as Father and lead with conviction. Book a free call with Mike and let’s talk about where you are and where God is leading you.

About the author: Mike Van Pelt is the Founder of American Family Renaissance and the CEO and Founder of True Man Life Coaching. He is a men’s mentor, speaker, author, and host of the True Man Podcast. Know God. Know Yourself. Live Fully.

Search

    Free Discovery Call

    Book a Free Call with Mike

    30 minutes. No obligation. Walk away with clarity on your next step.

    Book Your Free Call →

    Recent Blog Posts

    Leave No Man Behind | What Soldiers Know About Brotherhood

    Inspired by True Man Podcast, Episode 267 Ask a combat veteran what he misses most about his time in service, and you might be surprised by the answer. It's not the adrenaline. It's not the uniform. It's the men. The guy on his left and the guy on his right. Men he...

    Blog Post Categories

    Subscribe to Our Newsletter