American Family Renaissance

Convenient Christianity | Why America Needs Leaders Who Know the Way to Heaven

by Mike Van Pelt | Nov 10, 2026 | Podcast, Faith, Fatherhood, Leadership, Mindset

True Man Podcast — Episode 266 companion blog ·

“Do you think you’re going to Heaven?”

It may be the most important question a person will ever be asked. Last week, on 60 Minutes, Ross Douthat put it to the most powerful man in the world. President Trump’s answer: “I hope so. I don’t want to go to Hell.”

Then Douthat asked whether he could forgive his enemies. The President’s reply was blunt: “The answer is ‘no.’ I want to be honest… I do hate some of my enemies.”

That same week, Jim Caviezel — the man who played Jesus in The Passion of the Christ — said many pastors, priests, bishops, and popes have watered down the Gospel because they’re afraid of it.

And on Election Day, the evangelical share of the vote dropped to its lowest point in decades.

Those aren’t three separate stories. They’re one story. And on Episode 266 of the True Man Podcast, I connect the dots.

HEAVEN IS NOT A REPORT CARD

I’ve never turned to Donald Trump for spiritual encouragement. I’ve always viewed him the way I view a lot of politicians on both sides: Christianity is useful when it’s useful.

The 60 Minutes answer wasn’t new. It was a pattern. In 2016 he joked that being president might be his only way into Heaven. In 2025 he said there must be “some kind of a report card up there.” At this year’s National Prayer Breakfast, he said he should probably make it because he did a whole lot of good.

That’s a man who believes Heaven is earned.

Franklin Graham answered it the right way. Heaven has borders, he said, and only one way in: repentance and faith in Jesus Christ. Ephesians 2:8–9 settles it: we are saved by grace through faith, “not a result of works, so that no one may boast.”

I’m not throwing stones here. For years my identity was a performance review — tied to a career and a title I wanted and didn’t have. It cost me presence with my family. I know what report-card faith looks like, because I lived it.

And to the men who say, “But look at the judges and the pro-life wins” — policy matters. But don’t confuse a policy win with discipleship. Those are two different scorecards, and only one of them is eternal.

THE FORGIVENESS X-RAY

Forgiving your enemies doesn’t get you into Heaven. Christ does. But forgiveness is an X-ray of the heart. Jesus didn’t make it optional: “If you do not forgive others their sins, your Father will not forgive your sins” (Matthew 6:15).

So here’s the question I asked on the podcast, and I’ll ask it again here. Who’s your enemy? Your ex-wife? Your father? A business partner who betrayed you? If someone put a camera on you and asked if you could forgive them, what would you say?

Before we shake our heads at the White House, we’d better look in the mirror.

THE LUKEWARM PULPIT

Jim Caviezel called them the lukewarm, church leaders playing pattycake while the culture burns. “We’re in a time of war,” he said, “and good men need to stand up and start fighting.”

He’s right. Look at what’s become taboo in the American church: abortion, marriage, sexual morality, sin, Hell, repentance. We’ve built churches excellent at coffee and lighting, and afraid of the Book they’re built on.

Here’s the chain: the pulpit shapes the pew, the pew shapes the home, the home shapes the voter, and the voter shapes the government. A church afraid to teach the Bible raises people who can’t explain it — and they elect leaders who can say “God” at a rally but can’t explain the way to Heaven on national television.

THE PEW STAYED HOME

The midterm numbers make the point. White evangelical and born-again Christians made up just 17% of voters this year, down from 23% in 2024 and 24% in 2022, according to early exit polling. The evangelicals who voted still backed Republicans about 82% of the time. They didn’t switch teams. Many just didn’t show up.

Before the vote, Pew found the President’s approval among white evangelicals had fallen from 78% to 58%. I can’t read any man’s heart. But when a leader says he hates his enemies and treats Heaven like a punch line, believers feel it. Some got tired of defending it. Some checked out.

Still, staying home isn’t a statement of faith. It’s a retreat. As Ralph Reed put it, we have too many Christian speakers and not enough Christian organizers.

A lukewarm church doesn’t just produce lukewarm leaders. It produces lukewarm voters.

FIGHT THE RIGHT WAR

Caviezel says good men need to fight. I agree, but we must fight the right war. “We do not wrestle against flesh and blood” (Ephesians 6:12). The enemy isn’t your neighbor with a different yard sign. If we fight with hatred, we’ve already lost.

Our weapons are prayer, truth, example, and brotherhood. Pray for your enemies by name. Speak truth at your table and your school board. Live a life the Gospel has visibly changed. And stop fighting alone, the strongest thing a man can do is ask another man for help.

That’s why I built American Family Renaissance. Build the man. Strengthen the family. Restore the nation. In that order.

YOUR CHALLENGE THIS WEEK

Answer the question. Write out how a man gets to Heaven. If you can’t explain it in two minutes, open Ephesians 2 and Romans 10 until you can, then explain it to your kids.

Name your enemy and pray for him. Every day this week, by name. Obedience first. Feelings follow.

Back a courageous pastor. If yours preaches the whole truth, tell him you’ve got his back. If he doesn’t, pray for him, then have an honest, respectful conversation.

The President’s best answer was “I hope so.” I don’t want you living on “I hope so.” I want you living on “I know whom I have believed” (2 Timothy 1:12).

Know God. Know yourself. Live fully.

Watch/Listen: Episode 266 of the True Man Podcast, “Convenient Christianity,” is available now on YouTube at @truemanpodcast and on all major podcast platforms.

About the Author: Mike Van Pelt (MVP) is the Founder of American Family Renaissance and the CEO and Founder of True Man Life Coaching. A men’s mentor, speaker, author, and host of the True Man Podcast, he serves on the Board of Regents at GIVERS University®. Learn more at AmericanFamilyRenaissance.org.

Search

    Free Discovery Call

    Book a Free Call with Mike

    30 minutes. No obligation. Walk away with clarity on your next step.

    Book Your Free Call →

    Recent Blog Posts

    How to Pray When You Don’t Know What to Say: Honest Prayer for Men

    My Prayers Sounded Like a Weather Report If you've ever wondered how to pray when you don't know what to say, you're in good company. For a long time, my prayers sounded like a weather report. "Lord, thanks for the day. Be with my family. Help me at work. Amen." Same...

    Leave No Man Behind | What Soldiers Know About Brotherhood

    Inspired by True Man Podcast, Episode 267 Ask a combat veteran what he misses most about his time in service, and you might be surprised by the answer. It's not the adrenaline. It's not the uniform. It's the men. The guy on his left and the guy on his right. Men he...

    Blog Post Categories

    Subscribe to Our Newsletter